This iced fairy cakes recipe gives you light, individually portioned sponge cakes with a clean white icing and a colourful garnish. The batter uses equal weights of butter, caster sugar and maida with one egg, which keeps the mixing simple and the result consistent. At 200°C the cakes rise well in about 15 minutes and come out golden at the edges. The icing is a straightforward mix of icing sugar and warm water that you spoon directly over the cooled cakes. No piping, no layering, just a quick stir and spoon.
About the Recipe
The batter follows an equal-weight ratio of fat, sugar and flour, which gives the cakes a firm enough crumb to hold their shape in the paper cups without spreading. Baking powder handles the lift. The icing uses only icing sugar and warm water mixed to a stiff consistency, so it sits on top of the cake rather than running off the sides. Garnishes such as small cherries, sprinkles or little gems are pressed on while the icing is still wet so they stay fixed once it sets. From mixing to icing, the whole thing takes under 30 minutes.
Why You Will Love This Recipe
The quantities are small enough that you are not left with a large cake to portion and store, and the baking time is only 15 minutes. Each cake sits in its own cup, which makes them easy to serve and carry. The icing sets firm rather than staying sticky, so the garnish stays in place and the cakes can be stacked or packed without the tops getting damaged. For anyone new to baking, the equal-weight batter is forgiving and easy to remember.
Cooking Tips
The most common mistake with fairy cakes is filling the cups too full. Fill each cup only about two-thirds to allow room for the batter to rise without spilling. Make sure the icing sugar and water mixture is genuinely stiff before spooning it over the cakes. If it is too loose it will slide off rather than sit on top. The cakes must be fully cool before icing, otherwise the icing will melt and turn transparent instead of setting white.
Top Tips
- Fill each fairy cake cup no more than two-thirds full so the batter has room to rise without overflowing.
- Beat the batter until it is completely smooth with no visible lumps of butter before filling the cups.
- Mix the icing sugar with warm water gradually, one small addition at a time, until the mixture is thick enough to hold a spoon’s shape.
- Wait until the cakes are fully cool to the touch before adding the icing, otherwise the heat will thin it out.
- Press the cherries, sprinkles or gems onto the icing within a minute of spooning it on, while it is still soft enough to grip them.
- If the icing sets before you finish garnishing, add a tiny drop of warm water to the remaining icing and stir quickly to loosen it slightly.
Serving and Storing Suggestions
Serve the cakes at room temperature once the icing has fully set, which takes about 20 to 30 minutes after spooning. They work well on a plate for a small gathering or packed individually for a lunchbox. Store in an airtight container at room temperature for up to two days. Refrigerating them can make the icing slightly sticky, so room temperature storage is better when possible. Do not stack the cakes until the icing is completely firm.
Similar Recipes
Nutrient Benefits
Each fairy cake is a small portion, so the amounts of butter and sugar per serving are modest. Eggs contribute protein and fat-soluble vitamins. Butter provides fat and small amounts of vitamins A and D. Because the cakes are individually portioned, it is easy to keep serving sizes in check.
Iced Fairy Cakes
Ingredients
- 1 Egg large
- 50 g Maida
- 50 g Caster Sugar
- 50 g Butter soft
- 1/2 tsp Baking Powder
- Fairy cake cups
For the icing:
- 125 g Icing sugar
- 1 1/2 tbsp Warm Water
- Small Cherries, sprinkles or little gems to garnish
Instructions
- Combine the egg, maida, caster sugar, butter and baking powder in a bowl.
- Beat till smooth.
- Fill the cake cups with this mixture and place them in a greased tin.
- Bake them in a preheated oven at 200C for 15 minutes till the cakes are well risen and golden brown.
- Remove the cups from the tin and keep aside to cool.
- To make the icing, mix icing sugar with warm water till stiff.
- Spoon this over the cakes.
- Garnish with the cherries/gems/sprinkles.
Sign up for our newsletter
Add Awesome Cuisine as a Preferred Source
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use plain flour instead of maida?
Yes. Maida is a finely milled plain flour, so standard plain flour from the supermarket is a direct substitute in the same quantity. Self-raising flour is not recommended here because the recipe already includes baking powder, and using self-raising flour would add an unpredictable extra amount of leavening.
How do I know when the fairy cakes are properly baked?
The cakes should be well risen above the rim of the cup and golden brown on top after 15 minutes at 200°C. If you press the top gently with a fingertip it should spring back rather than leave an indent. If the centre still feels soft, give them another two minutes and check again.
Why is my icing running off the sides of the cakes?
The icing mixture is too thin. The icing sugar and warm water need to be mixed to a stiff consistency, meaning it holds its shape on a spoon without dripping freely. Add icing sugar a little at a time until you reach that thickness. Also make sure the cakes are fully cool, because even slight warmth will melt the icing and cause it to run.
Can I make the batter ahead of time?
It is better to bake the cakes straight after mixing. Once baking powder is combined with the wet ingredients it begins to activate, and leaving the batter to sit for a long time before baking can reduce the rise. You can measure and lay out all the dry ingredients in advance, then mix and bake when you are ready.
What can I use instead of small cherries or sprinkles to garnish?
Any small, firm decoration that can sit on top of soft icing will work. Hundreds and thousands, small sugar pearls, coloured sugar crystals or even a few finely chopped nuts are all practical options. The garnish is pressed on while the icing is still wet, so it needs to be small enough to sit flat rather than tip over as the icing sets.
