Paneer Peshawari is a North-West frontier style paneer curry that uses a simple layering technique to build both depth and texture in the same pan. The gravy starts with a cooked-down base of chopped onion and tomato, then sliced onion, tomato and capsicum go in later so they hold some bite. Cashewnut paste stirred in near the end gives the sauce a mild richness without making it heavy. Roasted and crushed kasoori methi, added at the finish along with cream, rounds off the dish with a distinctive fragrance. This peshawari paneer masala works equally well on a weeknight or when you are cooking for guests.
About the Recipe
The recipe uses two preparations of onion and tomato on purpose. The finely chopped versions cook down completely into the masala base, while the sliced versions go in later and soften only partially, giving the finished dish some substance beyond the gravy.
The spice mix is diluted in water before being added, which helps it blend into the base evenly without catching on the pan. Cashewnut paste made from boiled cashews thickens the sauce without any raw or gritty flavour. Kasoori methi is dry-roasted first so it crushes easily and releases more fragrance.
Why You Will Love This Recipe
Most paneer gravies are uniform in consistency, but here the sliced onion, tomato and capsicum hold their shape inside a smooth, cooked-down base, so every spoonful has something to it.
The finish is worth noting too. Roasted kasoori methi, cream and butter go in right at the end, so their flavour stays fresh. The paneer is added last and only warmed through until soft, which keeps it from toughening.
For anyone who enjoys Paneer Tawa Masala or similar dry-gravy paneer dishes, this one will feel familiar but a step richer.
Cooking Tips
The most common mistake here is adding the spice powders directly to hot oil, which causes them to burn before they blend in. Diluting them in two tablespoons of water first, as the recipe instructs, prevents this.
Cook the chopped onion and tomato base until the oil visibly surfaces on top before moving forward. If you add the sliced vegetables too early, they will overcook and disappear into the gravy rather than staying distinct.
Add the paneer last and keep the heat low so it softens without breaking apart.
Top Tips
- Boil the cashews before grinding them. Raw cashew paste has a slightly bitter edge and a coarser texture compared to paste made from boiled cashews.
- Dry-roast the kasoori methi for only 10 to 15 seconds on a hot tawa. It scorches quickly and turns bitter if left too long.
- Dilute all the powdered spices in water before adding them to the masala. This keeps them from sticking to the pan and burning.
- Add the sliced onion, tomato and capsicum only after the base is fully cooked. They need just a couple of minutes and should retain some texture.
- Keep the flame low when you add the paneer at the end. High heat toughens paneer quickly, and it only needs five minutes to heat through and soften.
- Taste and adjust salt after the cashewnut paste and butter go in, as both can subtly affect the overall seasoning of the gravy.
Serving and Storing Suggestions
Serve Paneer Peshawari hot, straight from the kadai, with roti or naan. It also goes well alongside a Paneer Biryani or plain steamed rice.
Leftovers keep well in a sealed container in the refrigerator for up to two days. Reheat gently on a low flame with a splash of water to loosen the gravy. Avoid boiling it again after the paneer is already cooked, as repeated high heat will make the paneer rubbery.
Similar Recipes
Nutrient Benefits
Paneer is a good source of protein and calcium, making it a filling choice in a vegetarian meal. Capsicum contributes vitamin C, and cashewnuts add some healthy fats along with a small amount of iron. The butter and cream used here are modest in quantity, so the dish is reasonably balanced, particularly when served with a whole wheat roti.
Paneer Peshawari
Ingredients
- 250 gms Paneer, cubed
- 1 Onion, finely chopped
- 1 Tomato, finely chopped
- 1 Onion, sliced
- 1 Tomato, sliced
- 1 Capsicum, sliced
- 2 Green Chillies, finely chopped
- 3-4 tbsp Oil (or as required)
- 1 tsp Jeera seeds
- 1 tbsp Ginger - Garlic Paste
- 1/2 tsp Turmeric Powder
- 1/2 tsp Jeera Powder
- 1/2 tsp Garam Masala Powder
- 1/2 tsp Kasoori Methi (Roast on a hot tawa for 10-15 seconds. Remove and crush in between hands)
- 1/4 tsp Black Pepper Powder
- 1 tbsp Boiled Cashewnut Paste (Boil 5-6 Cashews and then grind to a paste)
- 1 tbsp Butter
- Salt to Taste
- Coriander Leaves, for Garnishing
- A pinch of crushed Kasoori Methi, for Garnishing
- A little Cream, for Garnishing
Instructions
- Heat oil in a kadai.
- Add jeera seeds & allow to crackle.
- Then add in the chopped onions and sauti until light brown.
- Add ginger - garlic paste + chopped tomatoes.
- Cook till the oil surfaces on top.
- Dilute the turmeric powder + jeera powder + garam masala powder + pepper powder in 2 tbsp water & add to the gravy.
- Also add in the chopped green chillies.
- Bhuno the masala for 2 mins.
- Then add in the sliced onions + tomatoes + capsicum + 8-10 tbsp water.
- Mix & cook for a couple of mins.
- Then add in the cashewnut paste + butter + salt to taste.
- Mix well & cook for 2-3 mins.
- Finally add in the cream + crushed kasoori methi + paneer cubes & cook for a further 5 mins or until the paneer heats thru & becomes soft.
- Check & adjust the seasoning.
- Dish out the "Paneer Peshwari" in a bowl.
- Garnish with chopped coriander leaves, sprinkle with crushed kasoori methi & dot with some cream.
- Serve with Roti or Naan & Enjoy.
Sign up for our newsletter
Add Awesome Cuisine as a Preferred Source
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use store-bought cashew paste instead of making it at home?
You can, but the texture and flavour will differ slightly. Store-bought paste is often thicker and may contain added ingredients. The recipe calls for boiling whole cashews and grinding them fresh, which gives a smoother, cleaner paste. If you use store-bought paste, start with a little less than one tablespoon and adjust, as the consistency varies between brands.
Why does the recipe use both chopped and sliced onion and tomato?
The chopped onion and tomato cook down completely into the masala base, forming the flavour foundation of the gravy. The sliced onion, tomato and capsicum are added later and only partially cooked, so they retain some texture and give the finished dish a more substantial feel. If you skip the sliced vegetables or add them too early, the curry will taste fine but will be more uniformly smooth.
My gravy turned out too thick. What should I do?
Add warm water a tablespoon at a time and stir on a low flame until you reach the consistency you prefer. The cashewnut paste and butter both thicken the gravy noticeably, so a denser result is easy to end up with. Adding water gradually gives you better control than pouring in a large amount at once.
Can I make this recipe without cream?
Yes. The cream is used only for finishing and garnishing, so leaving it out changes the appearance more than the core flavour. If you want a similar effect, a spoonful of full-fat yoghurt stirred in off the heat can work, though the result will be slightly tangier. The cashewnut paste and butter already provide richness, so the dish is not flat without the cream.
Is there a substitute for kasoori methi if I do not have it?
Kasoori methi has a distinctive slightly bitter, herby fragrance that is hard to replicate exactly. If you do not have it, leaving it out is better than substituting something that changes the character of the dish. Fresh fenugreek leaves, finely chopped and added in a small quantity near the end, are the closest alternative if you can find them, though the flavour will be fresher and less concentrated than the dried version.
Nice I will try